By Mariama Marong

The Banjul High Court has sentenced two young men to 20 years’ imprisonment each after finding them guilty of violently robbing an elderly man at knifepoint, with Justice Ebrima Jaiteh warning that the courts will continue to impose severe punishments on those who terrorise innocent citizens.

The judgment, delivered on Monday, 29 June 2026, convicted Omar Camara and Modou Badjie of conspiracy to commit a felony and robbery arising from an attack on Bakary Sabally at Tallinding Farokono in August 2021.

Justice Jaiteh sentenced each convict to five years’ imprisonment on the conspiracy charge and 20 years’ imprisonment for robbery. The sentences are to run concurrently, meaning each will serve an effective prison term of 20 years.

According to the charges, the two men conspired to commit robbery before attacking Bakary Sabally in the early hours of 19 August 2021.

The prosecution alleged that the pair threatened the elderly victim with a knife and a broken bottle before forcibly taking two mobile phones and D15,000 in cash.

Both accused persons were arraigned before the High Court on 28 March 2022, where they pleaded not guilty to both counts.

During the trial, the prosecution called four witnesses and tendered several exhibits in support of its case.

In his judgment, Justice Jaiteh held that the prosecution had proved its case beyond reasonable doubt.

“Upon careful evaluation of the evidence as a whole, I find that PW1’s testimony is truthful, credible and materially corroborated by PW2 in respect of the first accused person, by PW3 and PW4 in respect of the second accused person, and by the voluntary confessional statements of both accused persons,” the judge said.

“The evidence forms one continuous, coherent and unbroken chain which points irresistibly to the guilt of the accused persons and excludes any reasonable hypothesis consistent with innocence.”

Justice Jaiteh ruled that the evidence established that the two men jointly threatened the complainant with a knife and a bottle before robbing him.

“Accordingly, I am satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that Modou Badjie and Omar Camara, acting in concert, threatened Bakary Sabally with a knife and a bottle and robbed him of two mobile phones and the sum of D15,000. The prosecution has proved all the essential ingredients of the offence of robbery contrary to Section 272 of the Criminal Code.”

He described the prosecution’s evidence as “cogent, compelling, internally consistent and mutually corroborative.”

“It establishes the guilt of both accused persons beyond reasonable doubt and leaves no room for any reasonable doubt. I therefore find both accused persons guilty of the offence of robbery as charged.”

The court also found both men guilty of conspiracy to commit a felony.

“After carefully evaluating the totality of the evidence before the Court, I am satisfied that the prosecution has discharged the burden placed upon it by law and has proved each of the offences charged beyond reasonable doubt,” Justice Jaiteh ruled.

Before sentence was passed, defence counsel E.Z. Bendou pleaded with the court for leniency.

Counsel submitted that both convicts were first-time offenders who had expressed genuine remorse for their actions.

He informed the court that the two men were in their early twenties and had been about 18 years old when the offence was committed.

The court also heard that Omar Camara is his mother’s only son and works as a carpenter, while Modou Badjie earns a living as a driver.

Counsel argued that both men had reflected on the consequences of their actions and deserved an opportunity to rehabilitate and return to society as law-abiding citizens.

However, Justice Jaiteh said the seriousness of the offences outweighed the mitigating factors.

“I have carefully considered the passionate pleas in mitigation advanced on behalf of both convicts by learned counsel E.Z. Bendou. I have also considered the gravity of the offences, the circumstances in which they were committed, the interests of the victims, the protection of the public, and the well-established principles governing sentencing, namely punishment, deterrence, rehabilitation, denunciation, and the protection of society,” he said.

The judge stressed that robbery is a violent crime that affects not only property but also the safety and dignity of victims.

“Robbery is not merely an offence against property; it is an offence against the person. It instils fear, insecurity and helplessness in innocent citizens who are entitled to move about freely without fear of being attacked or deprived of their possessions through violence or intimidation.”

Justice Jaiteh said several aggravating factors influenced the court’s decision.

“The victim was an elderly and vulnerable man who was confronted in the early hours of the morning, between approximately 4:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m., when law-abiding citizens are least able to defend themselves and when assistance is least likely to be available.”

“The convicts acted jointly, armed themselves with a knife and a bottle, threatened the victim with immediate violence, and robbed him of his possessions.”

He observed that placing a knife against the throat of an elderly man demonstrated a complete disregard for human life.

“Placing a knife against the throat of an elderly man demonstrates a complete disregard for the sanctity of human life. It is only by sheer providence that the victim did not suffer fatal injuries or lose his life during this terrifying ordeal.”

Justice Jaiteh also expressed concern that the offenders were young, able-bodied men who should have been making positive contributions to society.

“What is even more disturbing in this case is that the convicts are able-bodied young men. They are at an age when they ought to be contributing positively to their families, their communities, and the economic development of this country.”

“The youth constitute the backbone of every nation’s workforce. Their strength, energy, and talents should be directed towards productive employment, entrepreneurship, vocational training, agriculture, commerce, or the acquisition of skills that enable them to earn an honest and dignified living.”

Instead, he said, they had chosen criminality.

“Rather than working for their livelihood, they preyed upon vulnerable citizens under the cover of darkness, using violence and intimidation to take what did not belong to them. Such conduct is wholly unacceptable in a civilised society and cannot be tolerated by the courts.”

Justice Jaiteh used the sentencing to send what he described as a clear and unequivocal message to the country’s youth.

“There is dignity in honest labour, however modest the reward may be. There is honour in acquiring skills, pursuing education, engaging in lawful employment, and building one’s future through hard work and perseverance.”

“There is no honour in terrorising innocent people, threatening them with deadly weapons, or enriching oneself through violence and fear. Crime may appear to offer quick gains, but it ultimately leads to disgrace, the loss of liberty, and the destruction of one’s future.”

He added that the punishment should serve as a warning to others contemplating similar crimes.

“The sentence must send a strong message to all those who contemplate committing similar offences. Anyone who chooses to arm himself, lurk in the darkness, and violently rob innocent citizens must expect to face the full force of the law.”

“The courts will not hesitate to impose substantial custodial sentences where the circumstances warrant them. The safety and security of law-abiding members of society must be protected, and those who undermine public peace through violent crime must understand that such conduct carries severe consequences.”

Justice Jaiteh subsequently sentenced Omar Camara and Modou Badjie to five years’ imprisonment each for conspiracy to commit a felony and 20 years’ imprisonment each for robbery.

He ordered that the sentences run concurrently, bringing the effective sentence for each convict to 20 years’ imprisonment.

Facebook Notice for EU! You need to login to view and post FB Comments!