The Pegs, the Villages and the Border

By Yankuba Jallow

The latest Gambia-Senegal border crisis has brought back a question that successive governments have spent decades trying to answer: where exactly does The Gambia end and Senegal begin?

More than a century after the colonial boundary was drawn, that line continues to shape relations between The Gambia and Senegal. The latest confrontation at Bulock has shown how quickly an old uncertainty can become a security issue. 

In July, Senegalese forces demolished part of the perimeter fence of a Gambian military installation at Bulock in the West Coast Region, prompting The Gambia to condemn the action as “profoundly provocative and totally unacceptable”.

The incident did not stand alone. Days later, reports emerged of Senegalese security personnel ordering Gambian farmers in border communities to stop cultivating fields they had farmed for generations, with Senegal claiming some of the land lies within its territory. The developments renewed concerns among border communities and placed the long-running question of boundary demarcation back at the centre of relations between the two sovereign nations.

The Gambian government has insisted that the matter must be handled through diplomacy and existing bilateral mechanisms. Senegal, while also committing itself publicly to dialogue, has said some of the affected areas have been the subject of discussions for years and that its authorities have repeatedly raised concerns about what it considers encroachments on Senegalese territory. The dispute, however, is much older than the latest incidents.

For former Minister of Local Government and Lands and former Director of Physical Planning Momodou F.K. Kolley, one of the most important chapters, began when The Gambia attempted to establish a military camp in Darsilami.

Kolley, who served the Gambian state for 34 years, was subsequently involved in government investigations into the border. He examined old maps, searched government archives, led technical teams into the bush and physically followed sections of the border in search of colonial boundary pegs.

He said the investigations uncovered disputed markers, alleged tampering with pegs and villages that, according to his research, were once regarded as being on the Gambian side but are now treated as being inside Senegal. He also took part in meetings with Senegalese officials and technical experts, including a veteran Senegalese surveyor who, Kolley said, confirmed the position presented by The Gambia.

His account offered an inside view of a border dispute that has moved repeatedly between military confrontation, diplomatic meetings, technical surveys and political agreements.

“I don’t want Gambians to panic. My intention is not to cause any chaos between us and Senegal. I want us to tactically, practically and diplomatically tell them that they are wrong. Their numerous attempts to enter Gambian territory to do unwanted things should stop. The Gambia has never made claims over any territories,” Kolley said.

The Darsilami military camp

Kolley said the present dispute he became directly involved in began when The Gambia decided to establish a military camp in Darsilami.  The Senegalese responded by bringing military vehicles and other equipment to the area, claiming that it was within Senegalese territory.

“The Darsilami incident was a catalyst that prompted the Gambia Government to take border matters seriously by doing research and surveys along our borders,” Kolley said.

The development alarmed Lamin Sanneh, then Governor of the West Coast Region. Sanneh wrote to the Ministry of Local Government and Lands to report the situation. The minister at the time was Ismaila Sambou, who was himself from Darsilami. According to Kolley, the situation happened again. Governor Sanneh wrote another letter. He wrote for a third time, this time copying former President Yahya Jammeh. The letter eventually reached the president.

“When Yahya saw the letter, he called Ismaila and said, ‘ If your ministry fails to take action, I will take action,” Kolley recalled.

The incident forced the government to investigate the border more closely. 

“The Darsilami incident was a catalyst that prompted the Government of The Gambia to take border matters seriously by doing research and surveys along our borders,” Kolley said.

Former Secretary General Abdoulie Sallah directed the Ministry of Local Government and Lands to establish a team to search for the facts surrounding the border. At the time, Abdoulie Manneh was the permanent secretary at the Ministry of Local Government and Lands. Manneh assigned his deputy permanent secretary for technical matters, Saikou Sanyang Jnr, to work with the late Malamin Jatta, who was the Director of Lands and Surveys, and Kolley, who was then the Director of Physical Planning.

The initial assignment was to identify the border villages between The Gambia and Senegal. Kolley and his colleagues searched through maps and other records and prepared a list of villages along the boundary using the 1889 map.

The list was taken to the State House. There, Secretary General Sallah examined it. Sallah had served as governor in several regions, including Brikama, Kerewan, Basse, Mansakonko and Janjanbureh. He knew many of the villages and noticed that some border communities had not been included. That immediately presented an issue. Sallah raised this issue. This prompted Kolley to make the suggestion to the officials that they could not determine the boundary simply by discussing the names of villages on a table.

“Border issues cannot be discussed and cleared on the table as border pegs follow a line,” he said.

He argued that villages do not necessarily follow a straight boundary line and that the only way to understand the border was to go to the ground. Sallah asked Kolley what the most appropriate action to be taken was, and the answer was to form a team and visit the borderline. Sallah asked Kolley to establish a team. The timing of the exercise coincided with the groundnut harvest.

Kolley selected a five-member technical team. It included the late principal surveyor Madum Secka; Baba Cham from the Department of Lands and Survey; Amadou Batchilly and Abdoulie Bojang from the Physical Planning Department; and the late Sheriff Sonko, then Director of Governance at the Ministry of Local Government and Lands, responsible for logistical support while in the field. On the selection of Batchilly and Bojang, both had served for a long period in the Upper River Region as regional physical planning officers and knew the region well. The team set out to physically follow the boundary. They did not simply travel on established roads. They drove into bush and grassland in search of the boundary markers.

“We used to take the vehicle and enter the bush and grasses. The vehicles were used to provide us with light in the night to see the pegs,” Kolley said.

The survey was carried out during the day and at night.

“We worked both day and night, and completed the work within two weeks,” he said.

The team looked for the pegs that had been placed by colonial surveyors according to the 1889 map. He described them as cement pillars that could rise to about five metres, with a rounded portion visible at the base. One of the pegs he identified was at Alahin Bolong, in a wetland between Siffoe and Darsilami.

“There is a way behind Siffoe linking to Darsilami, which is a wetland. It has a boundary peg at the edge of Alahin Bolong, and it follows to the southern part,” he said.

Kolley said the peg was still there when he last visited the area.

The investigation also took Kolley back into the history of the boundary. He said the present dispute cannot be understood without examining the colonial arrangements that created the border. He said The Gambia’s territory was once larger than it is today and argued that the country was at latitude 15 degrees before colonial boundary arrangements reduced it to around latitude 13.5. He said that after the colonial boundaries were fixed, The Gambia was left with approximately 11,500 square kilometres, including land, forest and water bodies. For the specific Gambia-Senegal boundary, however, he repeatedly returned to 1889.

“There is a map of 1889,” he said.

Kolley said other maps existed but that the 1889 map remained the most authentic and accepted reference.

“The map that is final was the one drawn and pegged in 1889. That was the most efficient map at the time and still. To my knowledge, it is the only source of reference and remains the only source of reference as far as boundaries between us and Senegal are concerned,” he said.

He said to his knowledge there was no later map that replaced the 1889 map. According to Kolley, the work of subsequent technical committees of both countries was intended to address practical problems along the boundary rather than abandon the historical reference. The physical boundary, he said, was marked by pegs on the ground. That distinction became important when government officials began examining the border after the Darsilami confrontation.

The Darsilami military camp confrontation also prompted Senegal to inspect the border. According to Kolley, Senegal sent Colonel Krubally to conduct a survey. Kolley said the exercise was not sufficiently thorough. He said Krubally rushed through the work. The two men later met personally. Kolley also became acquainted with members of the wider Senegalese border team. Some of those officials have since retired.

Kolley said the border dispute did not begin with Darsilami. During the First Republic, he recalled, Senegalese authorities arrested the Alkalo of Jinack Kajata in the 1970s. Another incident occurred years later while Kolley was a minister. The Drug Law Enforcement Agency of The Gambia was conducting their normal patrols along the border when its officers arrested seven people suspected of farming cannabis in the Foni area. Senegal responded by arresting the Alkalo of that village and his son. Kolley said he subsequently invited then Interior Minister Ousman Sonko, former Inspector General of Police Yankuba Sonko and then DLEAG Director Alagie Morr to his office at the Ministry of Local Government and Lands. The incident was discussed. It was resolved that those detained by The Gambia should be released and exchanged with those arrested by Senegal: the Alkalo and his son. The proposed exchange brought the matter to an end without a wider confrontation.

One of Kolley’s major findings during his research concerned the Sabi and Vélingara areas. He said a boundary peg had been moved. According to his account, the movement of the peg resulted in the displacement of the boundary in a way that placed about 22 villages on the Senegalese side of the present line. He linked the issue to a 1972 border incident in the Sabi area. Kolley said the matter had previously been considered by Gambian and Senegalese authorities, as well as British and French officials. He said the findings supported The Gambia’s position and called for the boundary peg to be returned to its original position. He said there was a report prepared, which also contained the recommendations. He said he was able to verify and confirm this during his exercise. Among the villages he named were Fass Bajonk, Sare Pirasu, Baniko Kekoro, Baniko Ismaila and Genda Angaleh.

“These villages don’t know, but they are Gambians. However, they go to Gambian schools and hospitals,” he said.

But he said the current line places them in Senegal.

“If you go with the current situation, they are in Senegal,” he said.

Kolley said a report had been prepared after the 1972 incident, and recommendations were made, but the recommendations were not fully implemented.

“Meetings were held, recommendations were made, but actions were not taken to implement them,” he said.

The Sabi issue became an important part of Kolley’s argument that the present border dispute is partly the result of decisions made decades ago that were never fully implemented.

While doing the first field exercise, Kolley was called to an ECOWAS Early Warning Department meeting of directors of surveys in Dakar. Before leaving, he completed the border exercise. He then prepared a country paper for The Gambia after consulting former surveyors and senior officials who had previously worked on the border. Kolley said he conducted extensive consultations with people who had dealt with the boundary before him. 

“This allowed me to prepare a country paper that was presented in Senegal,” he said.

When he came back from Senegal, he prepared the report for the exercise he did with his team, but when the report was received, former President Jammeh had doubts.

“When the report was submitted, and President Yahya Jammeh read it, he expressed doubts as to whether such things could happen along our border,” Kolley said.

The former president ordered another exercise to verify the findings. The deadline was four days. The instruction was issued on Monday. The report had to be submitted by Friday.

A new team was assembled from the Office of the President, Defence, Local Government and Lands, Foreign Affairs, the police, immigration and Customs. Kolley said the officials were permanent secretaries and senior government officials. Ebrima O. Camara, the then Cabinet Secretary, was the head of the team. Kolley again led the team into critical areas along the border. Among those involved were ex-IGP Yankuba Sonko, the then director of immigration, one Landing Kinteh, Ebrima Sama Corr from the Office of the President and Saikou Sanyang Snr from the Ministry of Local Government and Lands, among others.

Omar Sampo Ceesay, then a councillor and head of the Basse Area Council, played an important role because of his knowledge of the Upper River Region.

“He knows his region very well,” Kolley said.

Ceesay knew the routes between the border villages and helped the team navigate areas that were difficult to reach. The exercise began in the North Bank and ended in Foni and finally in Darsilami. The officials prepared daily reports. The late Karim Saho, then deputy permanent secretary at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, took photographs. The team eventually met at the Governor’s Office in Brikama, where the daily reports were combined. The report was handed to the Secretary to Cabinet, Ebrima O. Camara, for editing and submission to the President.

“We were able to meet our target,” Kolley said.

Following the investigation, Jammeh established a national task force known as the Border Committee. It brought together relevant ministries, departments and agencies. All regional governors were also co-opted. Kolley said officials from the Ministry of Interior, Customs, police, Foreign Affairs, Local Government, the Office of the President and other institutions were involved. Ex-IGP Yankuba Sonko, Ex-director general of Immigration Buba Sanyang, Momodou Sarr of the National Environment Agency, Louie Moses Mendy, now permanent secretary at the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education, Saihou Kawsu Kassama and Harry Sambou were among the officials he identified as having participated. The committee was administratively headed by Abdoulie Manneh, the then permanent secretary of the Ministry of Local Government and Lands.

“President Jammeh was so concerned, and this committee was set up,” Kolley said.

The committee worked on a national paper on the border. 

To be continued in the next edition

Facebook Notice for EU! You need to login to view and post FB Comments!