The Local Government Commission of Inquiry has identified serious governance and financial control failures at Banjul City Council during the tenure of Mayor Rohey Malick Lowe, citing irregular expenditure procedures, weaknesses in procurement and the handling of council land.
In its assessment of Lowe’s evidence, the Commission identified failures in the council’s oversight systems, including payments processed through the Mayor’s office without adequate supporting documents and land dealings that proceeded without proper verification, valuation or lawful allocation procedures.
The findings raise questions about Lowe’s supervisory responsibilities as Mayor, although the document does not establish that she personally benefited financially from the transactions.
On public expenditure, the Commission found that payments were processed through the Mayor’s office, sometimes through the Assistant Public Relations Officer, without beneficiary lists, invoices, retirement documents or other records needed to account for the funds.
The payments included spending on media services, catering, printing, equipment hire, LED screens and other event-related services. The Commission’s legal assessment said the use of cash advances, imprests and informal sourcing, without following the required procurement procedures, breached public procurement and financial management requirements.
It also identified the absence of effective expenditure thresholds at the council, despite Lowe acknowledging that she had raised the need for such controls with the Chief Executive Officer.
The Commission said the failure to formalise and enforce spending limits weakened statutory checks and exposed council funds to risks of unauthorised expenditure.
On land administration, the inquiry found that the council proceeded with a proposed allocation involving Charbel El Hajj on the basis of unverified claims that he represented or partnered with a foreign manufacturing company identified as Hisense.
The proposed investment was presented as an opportunity to create employment for young people in Banjul. However, the Commission found that neither the Mayor, the Chief Executive Officer nor the council verified the existence or commitment of the purported investor.
Lowe acknowledged that the council had no documentary proof of the alleged investor, partnership agreement or feasibility of the proposed factory.
The Commission further found that the initial applicant never received a formal allocation or lease. A letter dated 30 April 2019 only conveyed the council’s agreement in principle to allow access to the land pending a formal agreement.
Despite the absence of a completed allocation, the council later dealt with EMKAY Stores, owned by Nandu Rajwani, after El Hajj purported to transfer the land to the business.
The inquiry found that the subsequent lease referred to council resolutions and approvals that had not specifically been granted in EMKAY Stores’ favour, raising concerns about the legality of the transaction and the protection of council property.
The Commission also questioned the undocumented land price, which Lowe recalled as either D20,000 or D25,000 per square metre, resulting in a total value of D2 million or D2.5 million.
Beyond the land transaction, the Commission identified institutional weaknesses at the council, including its prolonged operation without standing orders and the absence of effective written reporting between the Mayor and the Chief Executive Officer.
Lowe acknowledged that much of the communication between her office and the CEO was verbal and that she did not routinely receive written reports or minutes of senior management meetings.
The Commission said these weaknesses undermined oversight and accountability. It also concluded that the Mayor’s responsibilities under the local government and public finance laws extended beyond the day-to-day functions of the CEO, who served as the council’s accounting officer.
Its legal assessment identified potential breaches of the Local Government Act 2002, the Local Government Finance and Audit Act 2004, the Financial Regulations 2016, public procurement laws and the National Audit Office Act 2015.
The document points to the need for stronger financial controls, proper procurement procedures, documented council decisions, lawful land allocation processes and effective oversight mechanisms. It also identifies possible exposure to recovery of public funds, corrective directives and institutional reforms.
By Adama Makasuba
Discussion