€44,207.85 in flight tickets

By Yankuba Jallow

The National Assembly’s Finance and Public Accounts Committee (FPAC) has identified €519,545.55, equivalent to about D40.83 million, in expenses incurred by the Ostend partner of a Banjul City Council project that the committee described as ineligible.

The expenses included €44,207.85 in flight tickets, €17,545 in audit fees paid to Ernst & Young Bedrijfsrevisoren, and €299,982.85 in salaries for Jonas Scherrens, the Project Coordinator, and Peter Vanslambrouck, the City Link Coordinator.

FPAC recommended that the co-partner refund the ineligible expenses and that the money be used for the completion and maintenance of the project. The finding was among a series of issues identified by the committee in its review of the National Audit Reports on the Banjul City Council project.

FPAC also examined allowances paid to members of the project steering committee. From February 2021 to December 2022, members received D7,500 a month, while the Internal Auditor received D5,000. From January 2023, the Chairperson’s allowance increased to D15,000, while other members received D12,000. From March 2024, following restructuring, the Chairperson’s allowance increased again to D19,125, while other members received D10,000.

The committee said there was no documentary evidence supporting the increases or formal approval for the revised allowances. Between February 2021 and December 2023, D3,187,525 was spent on steering committee allowances, according to FPAC. The committee recommended that the current CEO recover all unapproved allowances within 60 days after the report was tabled.

FPAC also found that the steering committee was not made up of all the people required under the Framework Partnership Agreement. The agreement required representatives from the Department of Community Development under the Ministry of Local Government and Lands and the National Environment Agency to be part of the committee.

But the committee said there was no evidence that representatives of those institutions had been invited to steering committee meetings, including when their expertise was relevant to decisions. FPAC recommended that all relevant stakeholders be included in project steering committees.

The committee also examined training and scholarship activities under the project. FPAC said there were no reports for retreats, training sessions and related activities. It also found no established criteria for awarding scholarships, which totalled D3,142,680. The absence of reports meant the committee said it could not determine the objectives and results of the training activities or the basis on which scholarship beneficiaries were selected. It recommended that every retreat, training session and related activity have a written report setting out its objectives, results and feedback.

Recruitment under the project also came under scrutiny. The committee said eight staff members had been recruited but there was no evidence of interviews, selection criteria or documents showing how the decisions were made. The resignation of Finance Manager Ndey I. Touray in August 2021 and the appointment of Muhammed Cham in October 2021 were also described as undocumented. FPAC called for a clear recruitment process, including job advertisements, interview questions, candidate assessments, selection criteria and records of final decisions. The same issue was found among health and Burns Wood support staff. Fourteen people were listed as health consultants and support staff connected to the Burns Wood Centre at the Edward Francis Small Teaching Hospital. The committee said there were no interview records, selection criteria, identification documents or qualification records for the personnel. It recommended that standard recruitment procedures be introduced and that records of qualifications and selection decisions be maintained.

The committee also examined construction work at Crab Island. This included a contract for the renovation and rehabilitation of Crab Island buildings signed on 31 December 2021 between Banjul City Council and Jalakolong Construction Company. The contract was worth D5,703,976.70. FPAC said D2,507,880.68 had been paid but the work remained unfinished. Jalakolong later cited bankruptcy and asked the council for financial assistance. The request was not granted. The committee said a warning letter had earlier been sent to the contractor because of concerns about the progress of the work.

A business search, according to the report, showed that Jalakolong Trading Enterprise was registered as a sole proprietorship on 11 May 2021 but had not submitted annual returns or renewed its registration. The report said this “suggests that Jalakolong may have been established to fraudulently divert project funds”.

The contract was terminated in August 2022 and later awarded to ECOFARMS under the same terms. But the committee said the renovation remained incomplete at the time of the report. It recommended reimbursement of the relevant amount by the Finance Manager and CEO.

The project also paid D233,000 to ANK Analytics Ltd for accounting software. FPAC said the software was never delivered and was not used by the project. It recommended that the Finance Manager and CEO immediately reimburse the money and that ANK Analytics Ltd be investigated by police for what the committee described as “fraudulent misrepresentation among other things”.

Three separate payments for the design of a Crab Island masterplan also came under scrutiny. The payments totalled D380,000 whereas D110,000 to Njabot Construction Company, D130,000 to SM Bayo and D140,000 to GAM Engineering. The committee said two masterplans had been provided to the audit team, but there was no explanation for why three contractors were engaged. It also said the masterplan itself could not be obtained for verification despite repeated requests. FPAC recommended that the full D380,000 be reimbursed by the contractors within 45 days.

The committee also examined a contract awarded to Eco Farm’s Ecology Construction for the reconstruction and rehabilitation of Crab Island Upper Basic School buildings. Lot 1 was valued at D8,773,201, with an expected completion period of eight months. FPAC said the contract later ran beyond 24 months and remained incomplete. It also found differences between the agreed payment schedule and the amounts actually paid. Lot 2, covering Buildings A, A1 and B, was valued at D3,601,953. The contract provided for four stages of payment linked to construction milestones. But the committee said seven payments totalling D2,413,307.50 were made and did not match the payment terms in the contract. It recommended that the contractors reimburse the full amount within 60 days and provide evidence for verification.

Facebook Notice for EU! You need to login to view and post FB Comments!